Beliefnet
  • home
  • community
  • blogs
  • video
  • newsletters
  • dios es bueno
rss twitter facebook
Log in Sign up
  • Faiths & Prayer
    • I Love Jesus Online
    • Belief-o-Matic
    • Faith Leaders
    • Prayer
    • Christianity
    • Catholic
    • Prayables
    • Buddhism
    • Judaism
    • Islam
    • Hinduism
    • More Faiths
    • Popular on beliefnet now
    • Missional Living For My Mother: In Praise of a Life Lived Click here to read more ...
    • popular image Chasing an Elusive God An excerpt from the new book.
    • pulpit Why Christianity Is Dying But Spirituality Is Thriving? Dr. Steve McSwain looks at the changing shape of Christianity in ...
    see more inspiring features
    At Beliefnet, we have the largest collection of inspirational and faith newsletters available on the web.
    see more inspiring features
  • Inspiration
    • Angels
    • Inspirational Quotes Search
    • Inspirational Books
    • Cause of the Month
    • Popular on beliefnet now
    • Blowing a Shofar On the Frontlines An interview with Yael Eckstein, Senior Vice President of the ...
    • popular image Ray Liotta, Seth Green Join an All-Star Cast in Indie Film ‘The Identical’ “We want to bring films with a redeeming value to the world. One of ...
    • popular image A Life of Hope The fact that you’re standing here today with breath in your lungs ...
    see more inspiring features
    At Beliefnet, we have the largest collection of inspirational and faith newsletters available on the web.
    see more inspiring features
  • Health
    • Healthy Living
    • Emotional Health
    • Physical Health
    • Health Support for Women
    • Health Videos
    • Weight Loss
    • Health Support
    • Popular on beliefnet now
    • popular image Habits for a Heart Healthy Lifestyle Heart disease is a top killer worldwide -- but our lifestyle choices ...
    • popular image Emotional Equations Using brilliantly simple math that illuminates universal emotional ...
    • Heart lollipop and woman with candy surrounding her head Are You a Compulsive or Binge Eater? Do you struggle with your weight? Find out more about compulsive and ...
    see more inspiring features
    At Beliefnet, we have the largest collection of inspirational and faith newsletters available on the web.
    see more inspiring features
  • Entertainment
    • Music
    • Movies and TV
    • Quizzes
    • Travel
    • Sports
    • Jokes
    • The Bible
    • Celebrity Faith Database
    • Audio Adrenaline
    • Book Corner
    • Movie Corner
    • Daily Horoscope
    • Popular on beliefnet now
    • popular image Ray Liotta, Seth Green Join an All-Star Cast in Indie Film ‘The Identical’ “We want to bring films with a redeeming value to the world. One of ...
    • 12 Prayers for Christmas Faith, Freedom and Rocker John Schlitt “We are making choices on greed and stupidity. The truth is that our ...
    • robert griffin 3 Robert Griffin III: Not the Average Rookie Washington Redskins quarterback Robert Griffin III continues to wow ...
    see more inspiring features
    At Beliefnet, we have the largest collection of inspirational and faith newsletters available on the web.
    see more inspiring features
  • Wellness
    • Meditation
    • Yoga
    • Environment
    • Personal Growth
    • Transform Your Life
    • Popular on beliefnet now
    • popular image Green Powders to Add to Your Diet Now Green powders are a great way to boost your health, keep your energy ...
    • popular image Natural Deodorants That Actually Work What's that smell? Not us! We’ve been on a mission to find the best ...
    • Contemplative woman Birth of a Habit How long does it take to form a new habit? How long should it take ...
    see more inspiring features
    At Beliefnet, we have the largest collection of inspirational and faith newsletters available on the web.
    see more inspiring features
  • Love & Family
    • Relationships
    • Parenting
    • Teens
    • Caregiving
    • Heloise Hints
    • Recipes
    • Pets
    • Holidays
    • Life Events
    • Popular on beliefnet now
    • madly in love book cover Madly In Love With ME “I will never settle for less than my heart and soul desire.”
    • popular image Is It Love If You're All Cranky When You Give It? Love is the answer to everything in life.
    • popular image Living A Meaningful Life You are what you love and you love whatever you give your attention ...
    see more inspiring features
    At Beliefnet, we have the largest collection of inspirational and faith newsletters available on the web.
    see more inspiring features
  • News
    • Politic-o-Matic
    • Popular on beliefnet now
    • popular image "The Bible" a Labor of Love for Famed Producer, Wife The five-week, 10-hour TV special was nurtured by "Touched by an ...
    • popular image "The Bible" a Labor of Love for Famed Producer, Wife The five-week, 10-hour TV special was nurtured by "Touched by an ...
    • popular image Who Should Be Allowed to Pray for President Obama? It seems preposterous, but there’s a major debate over who is worthy ...
    see more inspiring features
    At Beliefnet, we have the largest collection of inspirational and faith newsletters available on the web.
    see more inspiring features
Home People Forums Groups Photos Video Journals Prayer Circles
Search Community
Help
    Home Home Journal Journal Photo Gallery Photo Gallery Video Gallery Video Gallery Calendar Calendar Friends Friends Groups Groups
    Joe68
    Joe68

    Level 3 Member

    Points: 4265

    Send Message
    Add to Friends
    Block Member
    Invite to Group
    Report this User
    Navigation
    • My Profile
    • Journal
    • Photos
    • Videos
    • Calendar
      • View Calendar
      • Upcoming Events
    • Friends
    • Groups
    Advertisement

Journal

    How do we know that the Gospel writers got it right?

    Wednesday, February 15, 2012, 12:14 PM [General]

     If the date for Christ’s crucifixion is around 30AD

    And

    MT was written in the late 50’s to early 60’s;
    MK was written in the mid to late 60’s;
    LK was written in the early 60’s
    JN was written in the 70’s to the turn of the century.

    Then it is correct to say that there was a delay in writing the Gospels; at least 25 years for MT, 30 years for MK and LK, and 35+ years for JN.

    *all dates are estimates or approximations*

    There are, however, some valid reasons for not providing a written Gospel early on:

    The general population was not literate. There was not much, if anything, in their lifestyles that would demand them to be so. Also there were no printing presses so the dissemination of reading materials was very time consuming and very expensive. Which made reading and writing only something the elite would have access to, for the most part.

    So if it was the goal of the disciples in the first century was to reach as many people as possible with the Gospel, it would have been counterproductive to write it down. Thus it was the speaking of the Gospel, or the oral proclamation of the Gospel that was most effective.

    In Acts one can see that the church is quickly growing and spreading. There is no way to conceive this as happening if they had to wait to write and distribute scrolls or codices . And then, I suppose, teach everyone to read.

    In any case, the time between Jesus’ crucifixion and the writing of the Gospels was not a static period. The Gospel was preached, disciples were made, and that happened over and over again. Thousands of times. The disciples, not just the 12, but all of Christ’s disciples would have heard the stories of Christ’s words and deeds many, many times. This is a very important point to remember.

    Only when the Apostles were starting to die off – and it seemed likely that Christ was not coming back any time soon – did there seem to be any motivation to write the Gospels.

    Now lets take a look at my question:

    After Matthew wrote his Gospel, let’s suppose that it is read in a public meeting. What would have happened if Matthew had decided to change a few things here and there?

    The people would have known if there were anything nefarious going on. Why? Because they already knew the Gospel story in side and out; they’ve heard it – as I said many, many times before – and Matthew’s Gospel would NOT have been accepted.

    As I understand it one of the hallmarks of whether a book made it into the canon the fact that it was accepted by the church – i.e. the people. This is one thing I could point to as showing that the Gospel writers got it right; their writings were in harmony with what was already known. Also it is most probable that there were many eyewitnesses to the events and words of Christ who were still alive. The Apostles were not writing new stuff, so it could be checked.

    Now if the Gospel writers had a penchant for changing anything one would have been the disciples being rebuked by Jesus or their “dullness” in understanding Jesus, or their attempting to position themselves for leadership. But all that “embarrassing” stuff in still there. This is an indicator that they were telling a true story.

    Also all four gospels say that a woman discovered the empty tomb and were the first to learn that Jesus was alive. The significance of that? In those days, in that society, women were considered poor witnesses due to their “vanity and rashness”. They were so undependable that a testimony from one man equaled that of 100 women. Why would they leave that in if they were trying to make the story more believable? They obviously were more concerned with telling it like it happened.

    Now I already accept the fact the early widespread distribution of NT books after they were written was a sort of control – i.e. any changes would have been noticed. Well that is exactly what the widespread distribution of the “oral proclamation” of the Gospel was – a control so any changes would have been noticed.

    So the answer my question: “How do we know that the NT writers got it right before they sat down to write”, would be that the written Gospels were NOT the first time that story was told. The collective memory of the Christian community, who were very familiar with the Gospel by its constant retelling throughout the years and its confirmation by eyewitnesses who were still alive, served as the control for the Apostles accuracy.

    0 (0 Ratings)
    Tweet

    Comments (0)

Recent Journal Posts

    • An example of Joseph Smith ability as a translator:
    • Joseph smith and the Book of Abraham
    • How do we know that the Gospel writers got it right?
    • Mormons, Margret Barker, Elohim, and Jehovah
    • Luther's Gospel of Straw

Journal Categories

    General (9)



beliefnet rss twitter facebook
Advertise with Us
  • Advertisers
  • Specifications
  • Demographics
  • Contact Us
Resources
  • Christianity
  • Catholic
  • Atheist
  • Judaism
  • Muslim
  • Buddhist
  • Mormon
  • Pagan
  • Hinduism
  • Scientology
  • Taoism
  • Quaker
  • Bloggers
  • Videos
  • Quizzes
  • Quotes
  • Newsletters
  • Belief-o-matic
  • Celebrity Faith
  • See all faiths
  • Rules of Conduct
Copyright © Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved. Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.