| 6 years ago :: Nov 16, 2007 - 7:11AM #31 | |
|
I think there's a difference between obviously inviting every person in the class except one or two - thus obviously leaving a few kids out - and inviting a few kids in one child's circle of friends. It would be more hurtful to be left out of a good friend's birthday party, but to be left out of a party thrown by that kid across the room you hardly know? Not very traumatic. And I was left out of a lot of birthday parties as a kid, too (including those within my "circle of friends", even); I'm not scarred for life because of it.
I also think it teaches a bad lesson if the bully who pulls a child's hair then gets invited to that child's very cool birthday party. It doesn't matter how you treat people; you can abuse them and still benefit from their friendship. You can pull her hair and still get to go to her very cool Chuck E. Cheese party. Far from teaching kids that it's NOT okay to be mean, I think some kids will learn that being mean has no social consequences. And they're in for a rude awakening when they get into a milieu when nobody is forced to invite them anywhere. |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 6 years ago :: Nov 16, 2007 - 7:25AM #32 | |
|
Glad your daughter had a fun party, Steve. All in all, as a parent your most important responsibility is to her, and not to the kid who pulls her hair but might feel left out if (s)he's not invited.
[QUOTE=stevegraywolf;61255] Funny but my girl says that no one even talked about it a school after it was over. Seems it's the adults who are placing this notion of hurt feelings on kids who really couldnt care less...seems they are more resillient than their parents believe they are.[/QUOTE] I agree completely. I think we as adults are putting a lot more emphasis on the ill effects of not being invited to a birthday party. And kids as young as six years old are very rarely as socially competitive as we remember from junior high, when the kinds of things Marie and others mentioned are more likely to take place. And has anyone thought of this? Kids who really are desperate to socially belittle others are going to do it whether or not invitations are handed out in school. It's just as easy for them to come to school and talk about invitations they received by mail, e-mail, or phone. It isn't hard for them to find out (or guess) who was and was not invited. Or maybe they won't make fun of kids for not being invited to the party - it'll be about their clothes, or their grades, or their interests, something far more integral to their personalities. We'll never remove all the ways kids can make each other feel hurt or left out. Isn't it far better to teach them that it's wrong to put others down? |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 6 years ago :: Nov 16, 2007 - 12:37PM #33 | |
|
[QUOTE=iris_alantiel;73127].
And has anyone thought of this? Kids who really are desperate to socially belittle others are going to do it whether or not invitations are handed out in school. It's just as easy for them to come to school and talk about invitations they received by mail, e-mail, or phone. It isn't hard for them to find out (or guess) who was and was not invited. Or maybe they won't make fun of kids for not being invited to the party - it'll be about their clothes, or their grades, or their interests, something far more integral to their personalities. We'll never remove all the ways kids can make each other feel hurt or left out. Isn't it far better to teach them that it's wrong to put others down?[/QUOTE] [COLOR="Sienna"][COLOR="Blue"][FONT="Comic Sans MS"]You could not be more correct. There are always going to be kids that think that they are better than everyone else having learned this at home or not. There are always going to be kids that feel the need to prove their worth by belittling or bullying others. Sometimes they learn better & sometimes they enter adulthood with these attitudes. Life is not about fairness or who has the best car. It is better that our kids learn this early. [/FONT][/COLOR][/COLOR] |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
Viewing this thread :: 0 registered and 1 guest
No registered users viewing