Post Reply
Page 5 of 5  •  Prev 1 2 3 4 5
Switch to Forum Live View Whats the difference between Christianity and Celtic Christianity?
1 year ago  ::  Dec 29, 2011 - 3:35PM #41
Stephen
Posts: 148

Greetings, Marty,


If I were you, I would change the name of this thread to celtic spirituality. The idea of, and word, "Christ," while pointing to a very powerful influence, has from the get-go been confusing and provocative. More importantly, it can distract from the love of a Person, to relating to them in their "position" in the scheme of things. While this position is not to be forgotten, still we ought to love everyone in their personhood, not their position. His name is Yeshua. He is the Christ, but His name is God Saves.


Note that in scripture, to say that one is "of Christ" is a sin unto death. (1 Corinth 1:10-3:17 ff. Note that this passage is flagged as a unit by it's references to Paul and Apollos, which is last found at 4:6.). "Christian" is too close to "of Christ" for me.


The celts loved their bards, but knew better than to call themselves bardians. One-on-one, they loved each bard they knew by name.


 

Quick Reply
Cancel
1 year ago  ::  Dec 29, 2011 - 4:06PM #42
mfjfarrell
Posts: 236

Greetings Stephen,


Thanks for stopping by again, any new inputs are appreciated here.  However, I may be the most active member of this group but I am not the moderator (hehehe).  While I understand your point I see that it is your specific outlook on what you believe.  The Celts have always been 'spiritual' people long before the coming of Christianity.  To do as you ask might be a throw-back to the pagan days of worshiping Nature rather than the Source behind all nature.  Secondly, the Early Celtic Christian converts were VERY passionate about Christ.  They understood well their place in His plan to restore Harmony with him.  They were very much Christians, as are we in this generation as well.


They did attempt to break with the Roman Church when they saw things going off a bit and remained faithful to the theology of the East, which was once the theology of the Whole Church.  As history records, they later had to succumb outwardly, but Celtic Christian Spirituality has always been a matter of the Heart, Mind and Soul rather than a seat in a pew on Sunday morning.  You will find Celtic Christians but its impossible to find historic Celtic Churches.  Most of what we have today called 'Celtic Churches' are reconstructions based in either Catholicism or high church Protestantism.  Regardless, CC remains a journey of discovering the relationship between ourselves and the Source of all Life.


Thanks again for contributing, always nice to see some activity again here....


Slan,


Marty

Quick Reply
Cancel
1 year ago  ::  Dec 29, 2011 - 4:42PM #43
Stephen
Posts: 148

Marty,


Interesting facts about ancient celtic churches, or the lack thereof. In my talks with God about His church, He tells me that at present He has none. Many people try to help Him out here, He says, by building "their" church as His, but it is not the same. He said that He has a plan, and many aspire to be members, but that there is much confusion and distraction, and no apostles that are trained to go about their job correctly. And so, He mourns, the gates of hell go unchallenged.


He said that this ought to be of interest to any and all who want to grow spiritually, since the church is His main instrument for such "edification."


He confirmed all this through a rereading of the scriptures, for which He had prepared me through scientific, really celtic, discipleship in scholarship. That first of all made it clear that "walking humbly with Him" and "knowing His voice" was standard operating practise in dealing with the Christ. Then He told me what was up, and to put on my scholar's hat when I read the scriptures. And there it all was! In plain sight, and totally ignored by me and everyone else I knew who had read the book!


So, good on the celts for keeping what they had of the church discreet. The one that He builds will always be so, even while being "the light of the world." Go figure.

Quick Reply
Cancel
1 year ago  ::  Dec 29, 2011 - 6:20PM #44
mfjfarrell
Posts: 236

Hey Stephen,


I understand what you mean about churches.  He is God, the Creator, He is within all creation and well beyond it as well.  He is within all Life even if some would choose to deny it.  That's why we call him the Source.  Mankind is social.  We appreciate clubs, organizations, groups to which we can belong because we have a need NOT to be alone in this life.  If you look deep within the landscape of your own soul, it won't be a church you see there, it will be His face smiling back at you though!  We are never really alone or disconnected from Him.


The Celts tend to see life as a river, the River of Life.  It flows and we are within it and it is within us.  As you put it, "walking humbly with Him" completely surrendered to His design for our lives and His will which always brings perfection.  As a group of believers and followers, we are a church of sort, but not the man-made kind of brick and mortar.  Even those who would vehemently disagree with us are still part of that church because He is within them as well. (but that does take some more tolerance on our part!! (hehehe))


Well, thanks again for sharing and feel free to contribute anytime you feel the Spirit stirring within you...


Slan,


Marty

Quick Reply
Cancel
1 year ago  ::  Jan 31, 2012 - 10:46AM #45
Emersonbernard
Posts: 122

May 11, 2010 -- 8:36AM, mfjfarrell wrote:

Dia anseo isteach!


God to all here!


Greetings Stephen,


Thanks again for responding here.  In your last post you wrote, " The combining of the Celtic vision with the gospel of christ is the greatest success story I've found..." and I can completely agree with that.  However, the earliest missionaries of the church had a slightly different approach when bringing the gospel to the world.  First they learned the understandings of the people to whom they were sent, then explained the gospel in terms of that understanding.  In the Early Church, the gospel shared in that time was different from today's modern gospel.  The theology of the Church then was different from what we understand today, it lacked Augustine's 'original sin'!  That doctrine was stoutly rejected by both the Celts and the Eastern churches.


Actually, to the Celts, there was no concept of sin as we know it.  Life was about harmony and you are either in harmony with life or you are a little bent.  Even though the missionaries to the Celts were from the Roman church, their theology, at that point, was still aligned with the theology of the East.  That's the gospel the Celts accepted as in line with their own beliefs!  As the church in Rome grew in social acceptance, it took on the more aggressive nature of the Empire and dominance, not harmony, became the central theme of its message.


Today, when someone is struck by the peace and harmony of CC, they approach it as though it is something worthy of interest but never see beyond the transformation of mind that is necessary for living it!  They will then try to shape it in their own understanding (Western) and not grasp its full value to transform the world.  As one young woman put it, its like wearing 'green glasses' when you read the scriptures!  Cute, but not accurate!  CC has always been about surrender to the Will of Christ.  Its not about war.  Its not about dominance.  Our only struggle is with our own humanity, and once you see Christ within that humanity, there's no longer a struggle for control.  That was the real Christian message of the Early Church.


Anyway, thanks again all for your interests here.  May God continue to shine His Light upon your paths...


Slan,


Marty


Greetings, Marty.


You mentioned the "transformation of mind" that is necessary for living Celtic Christianity. Realizing that Celtic Christianity is a "way of looking at things", I'm interested in actual practices that can help transform the mind to that end.


Since we've all been raised and indoctrinated in the Western Christian mindset of Fall/Redemption theology, it can be difficult to look at things anew. Although, I'm definitely getting there - in fact, I believe I am already of a Celtic Christian bent; that's why I'm attracted to it in the first place - there must be practices that can carrry us further down the path.


My current spiritual practice includes: Centering Prayer, Holy Eucharist twice a week, spiritual reading, Anglican prayer beads, Daily Office at least once a day, and regular visits with soul friends. I'm Anglican/Episcopalian, which has roots in Celtic Christianity. I also try to live simply and recycle - in an effort to leave as little a footprint as possible on the Earth.


Are there any other practices that come to mind that might assist in "transforming my mind" towards a more Celtic Christian way of seeing?


Peace,


Shane

Quick Reply
Cancel
1 year ago  ::  Jan 31, 2012 - 12:53PM #46
mfjfarrell
Posts: 236

Dia anseo isteach!


God to all here!


Hey Shane,


You are 100% correct about the Western mindset of the majority of society! Its upsetting to me to here 'The Church' condemnation of 'The World' as though we are opposites camp in an eternal battle. I was raised Roman Catholic, later converted to Pentecostal but realized how similar they actually were to each other! Both believe following a set of rules will help you 'find your way to heaven'. I'm sure it works for some but I wanted more 'reality' and God ISN'T a set of rules and rituals.


I'm glad you have set out upon the Celtic Path, its a journey of discovery, both of the world around you and the landscape of your own soul. Again, I'll recommend to you John O'Donohue's 'Anam Cara' to help explain some of the principles we live by. To cut to the quick however, its all about Harmony!! Just as the Trinity exists in a Harmony we were meant to live in Harmony with Ourself, God, and the world around us, the 3 Harmonies. (a trinity?)


While I understand all that you do with prayer books, beads, set times and places, and they may have their place in your life, its really more about the simple act of surrender.  Again, first discover who you are, then surrender! While searching within yourself, you will see Christ smiling back at you, surrender again to him there. Understand His presence and purpose in being within your life! Finally, surrender to the world you see around you and see it through His eyes (not the eyes of the church who can only see corruption).  When you see yourself, God and others with His eyes, it makes the journey you are traveling so much different than a simple mental acquisition. God's passion will move you through your day...


Study, will help in learning. Seeing will help in understanding. Letting God's Spirit flow through you and move you and direct you will create a whole new understanding of what the Gospel and Christ's lessons here were really all about. But it all begins with surrendering to the One, the Source, that you find within your own life. Sorry, there are no rituals for that just the honest meeting of a creation encountering his creator. I'd suggest climb a hill or sail a sea or find a quiet bolder in the middle of the woods and sit quietly while He speaks to you. These are what we call the 'thin places' and they are always sacred to us.


Thanks again for your interest in CC. Please let me know if there is more I need to explain or clarify. I'm always glad to help another fellow traveller...


Slan,


Marty

Quick Reply
Cancel
1 year ago  ::  Jan 31, 2012 - 11:39PM #47
Stephen
Posts: 148

Shane,



Try these three steps.


1. get your hopes up, and seek for a spiritual mentor, with whom you can ponder or meditate over the concept of "by this we know" the truth.


2. Look into scripture, until you find an imperative voice command that strikes you as timely and good.


3. Ask God for a prophetic revelation about specific actions you are to take to keep this commandment. Discuss what you "hear" prophetically with the best mentor you can find.



I hear God telling me that these steps put the ball of your transformation into His court, where he will see to it that you make progress, and know what to do do next.

Quick Reply
Cancel
4 months ago  ::  Feb 05, 2013 - 9:14PM #48
wearewatchingyouman
Posts: 1

I'm so bummed this discussion has faded.... I can't find a decent discussion on this topic anywhere...  I'm so intrigued by this belief system, but I yearn for fellowship and guidance... The closest gathering of Celtic Christians is hundreds of miles away... Some great info and resources cited here that I'm very thankful for though.... Grace and peace to all....

Quick Reply
Cancel
4 months ago  ::  Feb 06, 2013 - 9:36AM #49
mfjfarrell
Posts: 236

Greetings Wearewatching,


Thanks for sharing your thoughts and feelings here. I found one of the major differences between Western Christianity (Catholic and Protestant) and Celtic is one of approach. The west always 'preached' the gospel while the Celts usually 'lived' it. In I Peter 3:15 we are admonished to make Christ the center of our lives, live that way, and people will ask us about the 'hope that they see within' us. Celtic Christianity is not about 'talk, talk talk' as you see on the Evangelical sites. The two key points for followers of Christ should be 'listening' and 'seeing'. Once these are accomplished, its time for 'living'!!


A few months back I closed my own site, CCS on Quicktopic. The conversation had died for over a year there too. We were part of the Third Revival of CC but I have found that educating people contrary to the Western way of thinking is almost impossible unless the Holy Spirit is already guiding them from within! Having been a Pentecostal Elder in my former chuch, I know the educational system is excellent in indoctrinating followers into a closed mindset. It works for so so many people but still falls so far short of the message Christ meant for his followers. Most people are complacent and content to know that God loves them and they will go to heaven when they die. Its all they really care about anyway!


With the Celts, the whole purpose is about sharing 'The Light' so that others may 'See' and then 'Live'. Personally, I've seen that is just too much for many to handle nowadays. People are social and Conformity is also comforting! 


I've been watching the developing 'Emergent Church', which incorporates many of the Celtic beliefs and understandings, but it too seems to have lost its drive and growth. I don't despair, I'm not really out to 'convert' others for my purposes and security. I'm content to live as I know the Lord has led me and show Christ to all who seek him. If you would like to know more or have speciffic questions you need answered about CC, please feel free to contact me either here or at mfjfarrell@yahoo.com. I'd be glad to share what I have learned.


Thanks again for contributing here..


Slan,


Marty Farrell

Quick Reply
Cancel
Page 5 of 5  •  Prev 1 2 3 4 5
 
    Viewing this thread :: 0 registered and 1 guest
    No registered users viewing
    Advertisement

    Beliefnet On Facebook