| 1 year ago :: Apr 15, 2012 - 11:16PM #91 | |
|
Mlyons has called nobody any names. He is making a reasonable and logical observation that a person who has persistently repeated the lies of bigotry is actually a bigot. It's like saying that Himmmler or Goebbels was a Nazi: it's rather apodictic.
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 1 year ago :: Apr 15, 2012 - 11:40PM #92 | |
|
No, Sherri - MLyons chooses to call the bitch-granny of all whores for HAMAS the bigot that she has demonstrated herself to be in the Playboy interview and on many other occasions. She's being slammed here for words she said which were a lot more sweeping than simply "the world is a better and a safer place without Ruthi Fogel and her children in it". It's got nothing to do with her purporting to be a 'Christian', I'm sure. Nor has it anything to do with the technicality of her American citizenship.... Yes, I DO question her loyalty to this country: it's my absolute right to, especially after she's impugned mine. I'm sorry you can't bring yourself to consider the idea that a person can be a great inspiration AND inspire profound revulsion at the same time. Charles Lindberg, who was in many ways a true American hero, was also an avowed enemy of free press and democracy - and a very vocal supporter of Fascism. (I tried to explain this in referring to Pound and Eliot, but I gather that was too esoteric a reference.)
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 1 year ago :: Apr 16, 2012 - 7:07AM #93 | |
|
Quote Leah: "Sherri, how about you confront the inustice of the vile lie that 'the Jews control the White House'?" Why is it vile and can you confirm it is a lie? Thomas worked in White House, she knows many people there and she would know a lot more than she lets on. She took a great risk and lost her job. A person who could not afford to lose their job certainly would not dare speak.
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 1 year ago :: Apr 16, 2012 - 8:32AM #94 | |
We have further identified for you the 'history' of that particular lie, from Henry Ford back to the Tsarist propagandists, and on back to the initial French satirist's diatribe which was against Napoleon III. Links to scholarly sources have been posted - you might try reading 'religioustolerance.org' - on several occasions. The research has already been done. Several times over. It IS a filthy lie, told ONLY by Jew-hating bigots. - I have NEVER seen it brought up by anyone else. No honest person persists in this slander and demonizing. And each time someone has explained it, Dos - you have chosen to decide to ignore them, for whatever 'reasons'.
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 1 year ago :: Apr 16, 2012 - 8:44AM #95 | |
|
Sherri, please remind me of when it was we all elected you 'board monitor'? I never voted for you - and I demand a recount!!!! Unless you can refer me to those election results, I am certain that I've got as much right as you presume to, to define what is 'on topic'. It really looks like you're trying to evade and dodge and weasel out of answering me there. Which is fine - you don't have to pause in your unqualified adulation of the dowager whore for HAMAS to notice that she's a Jew-hating POS as is David Duke and every other bigot who repeats the demonizing lies about 'Jews control the country'. That is certainly your absolute right to decline to discuss your current idol's clay feet..... It's even your right to complain about my being disgusted by your ducking and weaving. And of course it's ALSO my right to wonder if that label of "pacifist humanitarian" and "person of conscience" which you hold to yourself so proudly, is really all that accurate for a person who refuses to acknowledge hate speech when it targets "the Jews". Remember, Thomas didn't even bother to pretend she was 'only' talking about 'Zionists' - she said "the Jews". Exactly like Henry Ford wrote. Exactly like David Duke still does.
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 1 year ago :: Apr 16, 2012 - 10:44AM #96 | |
In my opinion, it should concern all Americans when those in positions of power in our government put the interests of another nation above our own. And the ones who confront these traitorous like acts, like Helen Thomas has done, should be encouraged, not reviled. Using hateful words, thinking hateful thoughts, are, I expect, choices every person has chosen to make in their lives. We all have the capacity to do good and do evil, and we all choose both paths in our lives in various ways and at various times, Helen Thomas and myself included. These words and acts do and often should invoke profound revulsion in others. Such actions are a part of being human we should seek to control and refrain from, in my opinion, but as long as we are human we remain susceptible to and will at times engage in them. At the same time, sometimes truths are spoken that paint others in a negative light, that others falsely call hate speech or hate acts, and that is, in my opinion, where Helen Thomas comments about the Occupation lie, as well as her comments about the divided loyalties of some inside our government. Making these type of statements is taking a stand for what is right and speaking out against what is wrong. Besides being moral teachings in many religions, these are also what I was taught as a child in American public schools to be American values. Reading about Helen Thomas life and how she very much sees herself as an American with American values, as much as anything else I expect these American values she was taught all her life have dictated the choices she has made in her life to take stands in difficult/controversial areas. To Kill A Mockingbird, an American classic, I expect stories like that have inspired many Americans, Helen Thomas included. Sherri
Moderated by
rangerken
on Apr 16, 2012 - 01:16PM
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 1 year ago :: Apr 16, 2012 - 11:28AM #97 | |
|
I agree, Sherri - I think your loyalty to the cause of the 'foreign government' of HAMAS has indeed clouded your perceptions as much as Thomas'. I think Thomas is nothing at all like Scout: she's a great deal like Rhett Butler, though.... "So, Mz Thomas - where are all the Jews to go once they 'get the Hell out of Palestine (by which, if you read her words applauding HAMAS violence, she absolutely DOES mean every square inch of Israel proper!)" "Frankly, my dear - I don't give a damn!"
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 1 year ago :: Apr 16, 2012 - 8:52PM #98 | |
So if someone has been educated on the anti-semitic lies, and continues to repeat them anyway, what does that make them...?
"No freedom without education"
--Thomas Jefferson |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 1 year ago :: Apr 16, 2012 - 9:32PM #99 | |
|
The very most positive way I could describe it, Mlyons, would be that such a person is an extremely slow learner.
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 1 year ago :: Apr 17, 2012 - 7:52AM #100 | |
|
Quote Mlyons: 'So if someone has been educated on the anti-semitic lies, and continues to repeat them anyway, what does that make them...?' It is a lie to you because it does not gel with 'your version' of truth. We sure make big huhas when Iran (or other) bans some books or some scholars entry into the country. But the western world has a meaner way of assasination - that of person's character and their livelyhood. So much for democracy and freedom of speech. Meaningles words. Yes, Leah, I ignore it because I was not born yesterday.
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|