steven_guy: Yes, I guessed as much. The idea that God created the light already en route to us from a universe that was deliberately made to look more than 13 billion years old is a real problem for Creationists. It suggests that the earth is at the centre of the universe and that all of creation is one gigantic con-job.
iama: When you read Genesis 1 you understand that our Creator-God created all things completely / whole / mature / etc.
When I bother to read Genesis, and I haven't in a long time, I realise that I'm confronted with a very ancient myth written by ignorant barbarians and that none of it is true.
iama: You are one of those who understand that the biblical God / our Creator-God, is too small / not powerful enough / etc.!
No, lucuspa didn't deny that god would be powerful enough to create the universe with the appearance of great age; they simply correctly pointed out that such an action makes that god dishonest. You need to read what people actually post instead of what you wish they would post so it's easier to debate them.
And the rest of lucaspa's insightful post follows quite logically from that original point: if the YEC god lies about one thing (as it must to create a universe with the deceptive appearance of great age), then a person can never know what other lies that god tell.
In fact, if you can accept that god lied to make a 6K universe look 13 billion years old, then you have to accept the possibility that god lied to make a 15 second universe look 13 billion years old; how do you know that the deceitful god of YECism didn't create everything including you 15 seconds ago, with all the false memories,etc. to complete a "mature" world?
It is obvious that YECism makes for very bad science; lucaspa's post makes it clear that YECism also makes for very bad Christian theology.
Been there, done that, found the primitive pre-scientific tribal myths.
I suspect I have a rather clearer view of Genesis 1 than you do.
--------------------------------------------------------- What part of "Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn" do you not understand? --------------------------------------------------------- Wind speeds of Mach 2 would messily disassemble most consumer electronics. ---------------------------------------------------------
The wonder of Christmas is that the God Who dwelt among us, now, can dwell within us. - Roy Lessin . "Father, forgive them for they know not what they do." . Justice is receiving what you deserve. Mercy is NOT receiving what you deserve. Grace is receiving what you DO NOT deserve. .
iama: You are one of those who understand that the biblical God / our Creator-God, is too small / not powerful enough / etc.!
McAtheist: No, lucuspa didn't deny that god would be powerful enough to create the universe with the appearance of great age; they simply correctly pointed out that such an action makes that god dishonest. You need to read what people actually post instead of what you wish they would post so it's easier to debate them.
And the rest of lucaspa's insightful post follows quite logically from that original point: if the YEC god lies about one thing (as it must to create a universe with the deceptive appearance of great age), then a person can never know what other lies that god tell.
In fact, if you can accept that god lied to make a 6K universe look 13 billion years old, then you have to accept the possibility that god lied to make a 15 second universe look 13 billion years old; how do you know that the deceitful god of YECism didn't create everything including you 15 seconds ago, with all the false memories,etc. to complete a "mature" world?
It is obvious that YECism makes for very bad science; lucaspa's post makes it clear that YECism also makes for very bad Christian theology.
iama: It is the evolution speculation which is The Lie!
Anyone holding to the evolution speculation - The Lie, is calling our Creator-God a liar!
The ravages of The Flood taking place during the one year + period, and the subsequent Ice Age, accomplished all of the topography and tectonic features of The Earth as it is today. There has been very little erosion since The Flood, compared to the erosion, deposition and subsequent sculpting of the sedimentary layers into the Earth's topography as it appears, today!
It all depends upon our worldview, whether we are forced to call our Creator-God a liar, or not!
.
The wonder of Christmas is that the God Who dwelt among us, now, can dwell within us. - Roy Lessin . "Father, forgive them for they know not what they do." . Justice is receiving what you deserve. Mercy is NOT receiving what you deserve. Grace is receiving what you DO NOT deserve. .
--------------------------------------------------------- What part of "Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn" do you not understand? --------------------------------------------------------- Wind speeds of Mach 2 would messily disassemble most consumer electronics. ---------------------------------------------------------