| 3 years ago :: Jun 23, 2010 - 9:41AM #21 | |
The sciences of this world are droplets of reality; if then they lead not to reality, what fruit can come of illusion? By the one true God! If learning be not a means of access to Him, the Most Manifest, it is nothing but evident loss. (Baha'i Faith) As to life's problems Einstein said it well - we can't solve a problem using the same consciousness that created it ...
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 3 years ago :: Jun 23, 2010 - 6:50PM #22 | |
I know when I came into AA and read the third step. I was balking like a chicken. But I certainly agreed with first step and was very relieved when I read the 2nd step. Our primary purpose is to STAY sober and to help others recover from alcoholism. it took me 6 months of abstaining from alcohol to see God in the steps. I have met atheists in the program with alot of sobriety and their wisdom and knowledge has helped me immensely. For the newcomer who has a problem with God, think of GOD as a G.- Gathering O. - Of D.-Drunks if you pick up a drink there is another G.O.D. G-Gathering O-Of D-Demons It's your choice.
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 3 years ago :: Jul 06, 2010 - 12:20PM #23 | |
|
Anyone interested in self-help groups without the god/higher power BS should investigate Smart Recovery, Secular Organizations for Sobriety, Men for Sobriety, etc. on the Internet. |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 2 years ago :: Apr 13, 2011 - 11:17AM #24 | |
|
Just wanted to say thank you for these posts. Aside from the negative comments, I did find this very helpful. I have been stuck on 2nd step for awhile because of the God stuff. |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 2 years ago :: Apr 21, 2011 - 1:03AM #25 | |
|
I shared this earlier today and wanted to put it to paper so i could remember it in a way that isn't so abstract. anyway, here it is. an Atheist's Second Step. |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 2 years ago :: Jul 07, 2011 - 11:36AM #26 | |
I've been in the program for a while now and here's what I've heard so many time which is also part of my story. When I can to AA I'd lost all my faith in a Higher Power, if I've ever had any. Once I got here I found a group of wonderful people who were all too willing to be of help. They told me I needed a Higher Power that would/could help me maintain sobriety when times got tough. As sobriety mounted I realized that these people were my higher power. They kept me sober. They certainly see more powerful than me! I was told to work the steps for that's what would make the changes in me so I could not only remain sobriety but enjoy it. Soon I began to realize that in times of difficulty when no AA members were around to help the steps seemed to kept me sober. Initiatively I seemed to know how to handle things as AA literature says. Now I've come to realize that it was not the people but the 12 step of spiritual growth that was making the necessary changes within me to remain sober and begin to enjoy life. At this point it became clear that the 12 steps were my higher power. The next phase began with my searching as to why would 12 simple steps keep me sober when nothing else did? Well I concluded that there must be a power behind/within these steps that had to account for this phenomena. So I now concluded that it was the actual power behind the steps that did the work but where did it come from? My conclusion - A God of MY understanding ... Am I special? To the degree everyone else. I know today my family and friends think I am. This is not everyone's journey of discovery, but, it is mine! Wherever you're at, don't stop seeking answers and looking for more and more. And as AA tells us - keep an open mind ... All the best ...
The sciences of this world are droplets of reality; if then they lead not to reality, what fruit can come of illusion? By the one true God! If learning be not a means of access to Him, the Most Manifest, it is nothing but evident loss. (Baha'i Faith) As to life's problems Einstein said it well - we can't solve a problem using the same consciousness that created it ...
|
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 2 years ago :: Sep 25, 2011 - 6:47AM #27 | |
|
Wow its been a couple of yrs since I was here, time fly's. The 12 steps of AA worked fine for this former atheist. |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 2 years ago :: Nov 20, 2011 - 2:17AM #28 | |
|
I tried the steps as an atheist the first time around, it didn't work, without God the steps had no power to overcome the will. I couldn't do a meaningful 4th step. Thats quite different from 'without God the steps have no power at all.' I learned the steps without God were ego powered just like the rest of my mind. Thats was something I was supposed to be trying to be rid of, not reinforcing. So I stayed insane. I became suicidal and had to admit my way didn't work, letting my ego re-write the steps to suit self can be dangerous and its definately futile, I might as well have tried a ouija board. It was the same alcoholic insanity, change without changing. The steps may be adapted for various forms of spiritual illness but not changed, taking God out changes the steps. Dr Bob puts it well. "If you think you are an atheist, agnostic or other type of skeptic , or have any other type of intellectual Pride that keeps you from accepting what is in this book, I feel sorry for you." God drove this alcoholic out of AA, but the pain drove me back. |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 2 years ago :: Nov 20, 2011 - 6:00AM #29 | |
you admitted as much with "but I really don't know". First you claim to know there is no God, then hedge your bets with "I don't really know", then say "I know there is no God." So what is it, you do or you don't know? Step 2 as written in the big book does NOT require belief, nor faith in God. Anyone telling you otherwise needs to read the book again, its right there in the black bits. What works for others in AA is something quite different from what you are trying. The power of the group is an awesome dynamic, its well proven, but humans do not have the power to remove the obsession that causes a compulsion to drink. Nor do human groups have the power to change another persons state of being. An AA meeting of 100 alcoholics doesn't add up to anything more than human power. Neither does science, medicine or even religion. I was atheist when I started, I learned if I wanted to really try AA I had to get honest because when I changed the steps to suit my atheism I was swallowing another BIG lie. |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|
| 2 months ago :: Mar 22, 2013 - 11:29AM #30 | |
|
Hi! I had totally forgotten about this thread I startd waaaaaaaay back! New developement on this front! In my city (Toronto) a number of 'atheist/agnostic AA groups' have started up here. In a story too long to tell, our local intergroup ended up de-listing these groups from their published meeting list and on their website. What is funny is the whole atheists in AA movement here has taken off. More of these groups started up and are thriving. I was wondering if this is happening in some of your areas. |
|
|
Quick Reply
|
|