Hi Wabisabi, Love you're name and it's meaning.

I guess I would also define myself as an agnostic and attended Unity for about 13 years. I left a year ago when I finally realized that my true beliefs were contrary to Unity and I felt inauthentic.

First don't force yourself into believing in God. Listen to that still small voice that is saying BS  or saying "but if this is true then why is this so...." Unity believes that all paths lead to God, but the church is actually for believers. I know what you mean about agreeing with everything but the God part; the church is psychologically sound and gives great advice for living your life. You will need to personally decide if continuing with Unity is best for you or not. My guess is that Unity is filled with a few agnostics, deists, liberal Christians, panentheists, and a few pantheists. Some believe in the goodness of the "Universe" and not God. You may want to check out liberal Quakers or Unitarians as well. If you live a life of gratitude, skilled behavior dealing with people, responding and taking action, you may find that you may not need a belief in God at all.

Actually the Unitys I attended were not very Bible based and infrequently referred to the Bible. Some may not even consider themselves to be Christian, but New Thought. In Unity, Jesus is a brother or way shower and not God. He is a representative of what you can achieve. He is considered to be in some way a superior teacher to other teachers like Buddah, Krishna, etc. The bible is read metaphysically/symbolically. I have known individuals who did not hold Jesus in the highest regard and preferrred Buddah (or some cult leader!)The church has Christian roots and you will find individual churches that vary in their Christian practices and beliefs.