My question to you , "So what if there are "similarities" between Christianity and Buddhism?
There are also "differences" between Buddhism and Christianity.
.
how many similarities are there?
and how significant are they?
do the amount to being coincidental or not?
there's enough money for free college and health care, it's not a matter of HAVING the money, it's a matter of priorities. and this country feels death and murder of foreigners through war is more important than the health and well being of its own citizens.
if these things are not shared, then which one does not profess them?
as the opening post has already stated... a minimum of 5
I think there was another post with 3 more.
there's enough money for free college and health care, it's not a matter of HAVING the money, it's a matter of priorities. and this country feels death and murder of foreigners through war is more important than the health and well being of its own citizens.
Buddha-Buddhist advocte all the things that I listed as do Christians.
To deny that they are not similar is to be biased and predjuiced.
However Christianity and Buddhism are different religions. Buddhist and Christians have differences in what, why and how to apply the things that I listed i.e. the devil is in the details.
they are not similar, and they are similar, at the same time.
the dissimilarities appear in details of WHY become a member.
the similarities exist in highlevel of WHAT they hope to accomplish with the adherent.
what they hope to accomplish is:
instill reverence in adherent, modify (in other words correct) behavior, and explain a reality outside what the 5 senses are capable of perceiving.
for Buddhists participating in this forum, it is impossibly painful to admit any similarity, otherwise the admission would have already happened by now.
and the additional 3. has there been even 1 post refuting these 8 issues?
how often does nature produce 8 coincidences?
1... yes
2... sure
3... maybe
4... not likely
5... don't think so
I would conclude they are significant, and non-coincidental.
there's enough money for free college and health care, it's not a matter of HAVING the money, it's a matter of priorities. and this country feels death and murder of foreigners through war is more important than the health and well being of its own citizens.
as the opening post has already stated... a minimum of 5
I think there was another post with 3 more.
What are the other three?
have you read post #44?
there's enough money for free college and health care, it's not a matter of HAVING the money, it's a matter of priorities. and this country feels death and murder of foreigners through war is more important than the health and well being of its own citizens.
Yes I did. Post 44 mentions what 1-5 "hope to accomplish".
Can you or can you not answer a direct question?
Can you "list" eight similarites between the Christian Religion and the Buddhist Religion?
Can you "list" egith similarties between the Christian Religion and the Buddhist Religion, that are not found in Islam, or Bahai, or Hinduism?
"Between those two religions". NOT between OTHER religions.
If I asked you what are the similarites between a mammal and a fish. I am not asking for the similarites between a mammal and an insect, or fish and a bird. Or between an animal and a plant.
"Between those two animals. NOT between OTHER animals.
I agree that they are similar. I am sure that there are other "similarities".
But those were not on the list mentioned by aka me.
My question would are they similar for the same reasons.
Do they serve a similar purpose?
I don't know why Buddhists have monastics or why Christians have monastics.
The same for the use of incence?
Did Buddha use incence?
Did Jesus use incence?
From what I have read in the Bible Jesus was not a monastic.
I don't think the Buddha was either. Although I have read only a few of the Sutras.
I would think that it is more probable that Buddha chanted and less probable that Jesus chanted.
According to the Bible and the Sutras both Buddha and Jesus "prayed".
But their prayers were very different. Of course the words were different, but so where the reasons and purpose that Buddha-Buddhist pray and Jesus-Christians pray.
if these things are not shared, then which one does not profess them?
There are some similarities, particularly when it comes to behavioral codes. Some years ago, I was reminded of some of the 10 Commandments when I first learned and read about the 5 Precepts:
1. Panatipata veramani sikkhapadam samadiyami. I undertake the precept to refrain from destroying living creatures.
2. Adinnadana veramani sikkhapadam samadiyami. I undertake the precept to refrain from taking that which is not given.
3. Kamesu micchacara veramani sikkhapadam samadiyami. I undertake the precept to refrain from sexual misconduct.
4. Musavada veramani sikkhapadam samadiyami. I undertake the precept to refrain from incorrect speech.
5. Suramerayamajja pamadatthana veramani sikkhapadam samadiyami. I undertake the precept to refrain from intoxicating drinks and drugs which lead to carelessness.
Upon closer inspection, there are differences. For instance, the precept to "refrain from destroying living creatures" refers to not only human beings, but to all sentient beings. (Snp 1.8) The approach to morality differs as well. Catholicism, in my experience, seeks to enforce moral behavior upon what are believed to be innately flawed beings who need discipline. My understanding is that some forms of Protestant Christianity emphasize personal choice and free will over traditional Christian fatalism. But Buddhism (according to what I've been exposed to) takes a very gentle and patient approach, an approach which validates the human ability to approach the ideals with gradual, mindful attention. Catholicism sees moral behavior chiefly as a means of pleasing God, whereas Buddhism regards it as a practice that more quickly chips away at suffering, it speeds the process up towards enlightenment.
But since this is a discussion of the similarities, I agree with you that there is certainly some common ground. In fact, moral codes of behavior throughout most religions in the world, not just Christianity and Buddhism, bear striking similarities. Though again, with different emphasis in the specifics of what and why.