Post Reply
Page 45 of 50  •  Prev 1 ... 43 44 45 46 47 ... 50 Next
Switch to Forum Live View Christian interpretation versus Jewish interpretation
3 years ago  ::  Aug 04, 2010 - 6:23PM #441
Kingdom357
Posts: 343

You have a lot of nerve criticizing me. You are following a Philosopher, who lived in the 12th century in Spain.  He and his family were ejected from Spain and moved to Eygpt where he studied Islam.  Islam my friend, does not believe Israel  to be important and does not thing the Hebrew scriptures are worth anything.  Congradulations on becoming a Muslim.

Quick Reply
Cancel
3 years ago  ::  Aug 04, 2010 - 7:39PM #442
LeahOne
Posts: 14,488

Aug 4, 2010 -- 6:23PM, Kingdom357 wrote:


You have a lot of nerve criticizing me. You are following a Philosopher, who lived in the 12th century in Spain.  He and his family were ejected from Spain and moved to Eygpt where he studied Islam.  Islam my friend, does not believe Israel  to be important and does not thing the Hebrew scriptures are worth anything.  Congradulations on becoming a Muslim.




en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maimonides <-  Much more accurate biography of Rabbi and Physician Moshe ben Maimon.


First of all, Maimonides lived most of his life in Egypt.  Second:  his family, like many in Spain, were faced with the 'Convert or Exile' edict  - this from the Muslim Almohades after Cordoba was conquered.


While in Egypt, Moshe studied at a yeshiva in Cairo (this of course was a school of JEWISH study).  He had also studied medicine at Cordoba in Spain, and continued his studies in Egypt.  He was appointed (I assume by the Muslim ruler) 'Nagid' of the Egyprian Jewish community - meaning 'Prince', in essence leader and judge of all Egyptian Jewry.  He was only 36 then, but had already published his Mishne Torah.  He practiced medicine, and was the physician to Saladin, and personal physician to the royal family.


No less a Christian scholar than St Thomas Aquinas was heavily influenced by Maimonides' work - along with other Scholastics both Christian and Jewish, and scholars of several fields too numerous to begin to list.


There's no evidence that RamBam ever 'studied Islam' - and certainly a person is capable of studying a faith while not adopting it.  Considering that Orthodox Judaism has pretty well taken his 'Thirteen Points' as required belief - I think Maimonides' beliefs are quite thoroughly 'mainstream' for Judaism.


Anyone suggesting otherwise about Maimonides' beliefs has certainly 'gone 'round the bend' - that's as insane an 'idea' as anything I've ever read in a psych case history.


One wonders indeed where such insanity came from.......



Quick Reply
Cancel
3 years ago  ::  Aug 04, 2010 - 8:25PM #443
Bunsinspace
Posts: 5,235

Aug 4, 2010 -- 6:23PM, Kingdom357 wrote:


You have a lot of nerve criticizing me. You are following a Philosopher, who lived in the 12th century in Spain.  He and his family were ejected from Spain and moved to Eygpt where he studied Islam.  Islam my friend, does not believe Israel  to be important and does not thing the Hebrew scriptures are worth anything.  Congradulations on becoming a Muslim.





BS"D


Didn't mean to offend you, just kick you in the behind a bit so you might open your eyes.  Jews don't follow ANYBODY.  Jews follow Torah and part of Torah is correcting each other.  Your history is quite a bit lacking all the way around the block.  Better to learn something about the subject before you speak of it IMHO.  Tongue out

Quick Reply
Cancel
3 years ago  ::  Aug 05, 2010 - 11:15AM #444
rocketjsquirell
Posts: 11,998

I think Maimonides' beliefs are quite thoroughly 'mainstream' for Judaism.


It would be hard to argue with that statement, even if one is perpetually perplexed.

Quick Reply
Cancel
3 years ago  ::  Aug 05, 2010 - 11:52AM #445
Beautiful_Dreamer
Posts: 4,930

Kingdom, just because people disagree with you doesn't mean they are criticizing or being mean. Granted, some might not say it in the nicest way, but challenging and disagreeing is what people do on a debate board.

More where that came from...

A new-ish forum for women

Beliefnet Community Host - Christian Faith and Life, Christian to Christian Debate
Quick Reply
Cancel
3 years ago  ::  Aug 05, 2010 - 8:10PM #446
Kingdom357
Posts: 343

That's very true Beautiful Dreamer, and I have been on many, many debate forums, and what most of them do is debate in a respectful manner.  I believe I should be able to expect the same here.  I believe in Almighty God and in Yeshua.  I am not a non-religous Jew.

Moderated by Merope on Aug 16, 2010 - 02:40AM
Quick Reply
Cancel
3 years ago  ::  Aug 06, 2010 - 7:30AM #447
river8101
Posts: 5,153

Kingdom -  Post 372 – This thread:  Christian Interpretation –versus Jewish interpretation:  2010


Kingdom admitted on this thread: “By the way, I was Avie, and then as now, I did not come to insult the Jews.  My mother was a Jew and I loved her very much.  My Aunts and Uncles and cousins were all Jews and I loved them as well.  Unfortunately they have all passed away.  I can't ask them anything anymore now can I”


Avie came on the Archaeology and the Bible forum as a fundamentalist evangelist and even though the thread was supposed to be about NEW discoveries and  ’only on new discoveries on "Archaeology and the Bible" , Avie disrupted many threads by constantly evangelizing and putting down Jews.  Here’s but 2 examples in the following thread.   Many more on other threads I have saved. 


www.beliefnet.com/boards/message_list.as...


Avie  (wrote)  in the following posts of that forum.  Bible vs History    It also appeared in MJD and in Judaism-Challenge and Critique (as the Jewish forum was once called.) After that and more,  she was removed from the Jewish forum.  Avie wrote:
 
”I can also truthfully state that the Jewish treatment of Christians down through the ages has not been all that wonderful. Also, the Jews were kicked out of so many countries because they all wanted to make money. They became very unpopular because they held positions that were unpopular. They were tax collectors and money merchants. People didn't like them. Not just Christians. They were denied their freedom by Muslims too. So stop blaming it all on Christians. It's just an out and out lie.”  [Post 38]
 
”As for what I posted, I posted the truth. I know that's hard for you to understand. The only thing people have against the Jews over time, is the fact that their greed runs away with them. It is a historical fact. What Jews call Anti-Semitism has nothing whatsoever to do with their religion. People dislike them not for their religious beliefs but for their greed and obnoxious behavior. There is very little anti-Semitism about it.”   [Post 43] 


Probably best to read it all.  I guess the poster didn't understand that the Church set interest rates for the Jews to lend money, and the lending was needed so that the Christian countries and their churches could finance business opportunities, commerce, trade and their many. many  wars.  Lending money was forbidden by the churches in the middle ages so Jews who in the past only lent money to each other were now forced to loan money to the Christians..  However, often the churches or the nobles or anyone in a trade couldn't pay back the Jews, thus they made them leave the country and accused them of all sorts of lies, which Avie/Kingdom wrote about.  And that's why people didn't like them.  They didn't want to pay back money they were loaned.  When the Churches finally realized how badly they needed money lenders (banks) they recinded the law and the Christians got into it.  However, if one reads their history, they will realize that the interest rates set by the Christians was much higher than that set by the Jews.  Therefore many preferred going to the Jews where the interest rates were lower and set by the Church. 

“Faith is deciding to allow yourself to believe something your intellect would otherwise cause you to reject.”
Quick Reply
Cancel
3 years ago  ::  Aug 06, 2010 - 11:55AM #448
LeahOne
Posts: 14,488

 

Avie,
} You get your information from early greek history.}}---------Again you misunderstand. I get my information from a Early Greek �historian�. Not a theologian like some others.
I have given you information on this before. But you ignore it.


} There is much written about what happened during those years, both good and bad. You read the bad, I read the good.}}------No. I do not determin what is good and bad throughout history. I am seeking an accurate portrayal.

} WE HAVE A MUTUAL ENEMY AND IT'S NOT EACH OTHER. IT IS NOW AND HAS BEEN FOR CENTURIES THE MUSLIMS. }}-------------Its too bad people think this way. I think it is sad. I am for humanity.

} Most of what I see you post is from Islamic sources. They hate both Jew's and Christians alike.}}-----------I read the same things river does and they are not from Islamic sources. You really should try to broaden you horizons a little more.

} Constantine was not a Christian until he was on his death bed.}}---------So what. You cannot deny that were it not for the Roman Emperor Constantine uniting the Christian Churches, Christianity would not be the same as it is today.
As a matter of fact, if it were not for Constantine there is a good likelihood that Christianity could have died out.

} I have been searching for the slaughter of Jews by Christians as you stated but can't find anything.}}-----------�Where� have you been looking?

And here's a post (#36 on thread) by a third poster, Circlefist,  who replies to 'kingdom's outrageous  'statements'  one by one.  I've put those replies into the redddish color for readability.


It's pretty clear from what River has presented that 'a/k' is simply an example of what I've suggested M'J' is:  lies, fakes and fraud.


Thanks, Rivvie, for showing us what 'a/k' is really made of......

Quick Reply
Cancel
3 years ago  ::  Aug 06, 2010 - 12:28PM #449
LeahOne
Posts: 14,488

Halsall Home | Medieval Sourcebook | Modern History Sourcebook
Other History Sourcebooks: African | East Asian | Indian | IslamicJewish | LGBT | Women's | Global | Science


In one of her posts, 'a/k' claimed she used the Fordham U site  and could not locate ANY material relating to Christian persecution of Jews.


www.fordham.edu/Halsall/ancient/asbook11...  <-- a general 'source' site for ancient history, with documents of the period translated - and then commentary from a RC Christian POV (as expected)


At the top of that page, we find the links above.  Now I can't be certain those links were there 8 years ago - but certainly today one simply has to click on the 'Jewish' history link to access a source of information of EXACTLY the type 'a/k' claimed she couldn't locate.

Quick Reply
Cancel
3 years ago  ::  Aug 06, 2010 - 6:44PM #450
Kingdom357
Posts: 343

O.K. River, but you did not post the things you said to me now did you.  That would be the thing to do inorder to be fair. 


Now as to that post, it is history River, I'm sorry, but I can't change history. 


At this time in my life I was doing genealogy and had found ancestors on my fathers side back to the 14th century.  It was then I decided to do my mothers genealogy so I sent an e-mail to the archives in Poland where my mother was born and received a reply that all Jewish records had been destroyed.  This put a damper on what I thought would be fun checking on my mother's Jewish heritage.  So I went  into it by finding out first the history of Israel.  Then why it was that so many Jewish people lived in Germany and Poland.  My Polish Grandparents were farmers.  They were Jewish, Jewish, Jewish and I in no way want to make Jewish people look bad.  All I did was post the historical evidence I found.


Next, I don't know why believing in Yeshua is so hateful to you, His teachings were Jewish not pagan.


Now as Beautiful Dreamer stated, this is a discussion board, instead of going into a defensive mode, why didn't you find out if what I stated was fact and if it isn't, post the truth so everyone can learn from it including me.

Quick Reply
Cancel
Page 45 of 50  •  Prev 1 ... 43 44 45 46 47 ... 50 Next
 
    Viewing this thread :: 0 registered and 1 guest
    No registered users viewing
    Advertisement

    Beliefnet On Facebook