I have an interesting question, and I would love to see peoples' opinions and thoughts on this. I've heard a lot of pro-choicers claim that using abortion for birth control is wrong. But I wonder what they exactly mean by this. Isn't abortion inherently birth control? Or is it something else? I wonder if the offensive part is women who's had many abortions because of repeated irresponsible (dis)use of birth control. Perhaps that is the real issue? But even then, is it wrong to use abortion as birth control?
If it really is more about the amount of abortions, then how many abortions are too many abortions? Is there a number of abortions that begins to raise a flag, or is more about the women's situation? If so, what situations are wrong?
I hope I formed these questions in a coherent way. It's been on my mind for awhile and I thought I might get some pretty insightful answers here! Debate away!
"Isn't abortion inherently birth control? Or is it something else? I wonder if the offensive part is women who's had many abortions because of repeated irresponsible (dis)use of birth control. Perhaps that is the real issue? But even then, is it wrong to use abortion as birth control?"
In my opinion, abortion does not prevent pregnancy but rather terminates it. Abortion is wrong to use as birth control as (I believe) it is wrong to play any part in socitey. When a child is concieved, his or her ontological state is beyond our perceptions to adequately reckon the child as a person or not (separate from any religious or faith-based argument that is). The fertilization of an egg marks the beginning of a process that will ultimately lead to personhood/adulthood (the potential is there), therefore abortion may take on the act of 'controlling' pregnancies but is nonetheless the extermination of life. [I realize that I am using personal pronouns to describe the fetus and i mean not to passively nor ignorantly aid my view. I simply cannot bring myself to refer to these lives as 'its']
"If it really is more about the amount of abortions, then how many abortions are too many abortions? Is there a number of abortions that begins to raise a flag, or is more about the women's situation? If so, what situations are wrong?"
One abortion is too many. A flag should be raised at the thought of exterminating life. Although the topic is delicate, even in the case of rape there are two, equally living human beings (according to my former argument). The option of adoption is available - there are many couples who struggle to have planned pregnancies for one thing. In this case a wrong can turn out for the good (even if it is for another) instead of turning into another wrong (again according to my reasoning above).
Please respond. I am eager to dialogue with anyone.
I believe that abortion at any stage of the babies development is sinful. Humans right from conception are growing until old age and simply because that person has not passed through the birth canal does not make him/her any less human. It is almost a primative idea to think that birth is the start of human life. Birth is just another step in the growth of a person.
I have an interesting question, and I would love to see peoples' opinions and thoughts on this. I've heard a lot of pro-choicers claim that using abortion for birth control is wrong. But I wonder what they exactly mean by this. Isn't abortion inherently birth control? Or is it something else? I wonder if the offensive part is women who's had many abortions because of repeated irresponsible (dis)use of birth control. Perhaps that is the real issue? But even then, is it wrong to use abortion as birth control?
If it really is more about the amount of abortions, then how many abortions are too many abortions? Is there a number of abortions that begins to raise a flag, or is more about the women's situation? If so, what situations are wrong?
I hope I formed these questions in a coherent way. It's been on my mind for awhile and I thought I might get some pretty insightful answers here! Debate away!
i think the only real issue with having multiple abortions is the toll they'll take on the womans body. Well, that and money--abortions cost more than bc pills.
Good question. I think it's inconsistent to say there is nothing morally wrong with abortions but there is with having multiple abortions.
The present halaucost is missing Hitler. That is the only difference.
I respect a wman who respects herself and knows that the baby in her womb is not a part of her but a totally individual life. To kill it is murder. Pro-choicers can whine and shout all they want, they are only fooling themselves and murdering babies.
